Wednesday, 2 July 2008

The problem in filming the Narnia Chronicles

In looking at what are the shortcomings of the film Prince Caspian, we would do well to look at what the author thought of such a project. C.S. Lewis himself was very much against film versions being made of his Chronicles of Narnia as he thought that it would lead to "buffoonery or nightmare". In many respects he was right: as children's tales they are very effective, but when as it were brought to a more realistic view film view they fall apart.



When placed in a realist setting the talking animals of Narnia are completely unconvincing, and this came apparent in the first filming of the Lion, Witch and the Wardrobe. It was a considerable improvement on the BBC television dramatisation which ended up using soft toys! Nevertheless despite the best efforts made the talking animals betray themselves as computer graphics.


Another example that could be said to be unrealistic is the idea of children sword fighting adults: it sounds attractive in a book but comes out as absurd in reality. Also the geography and features of Narnia are not at all convincing when placed in a realist setting.

Probably the most effective way to film the Chronicles of Narnia would be to do them in animated form, rather than in live action. A fairly presentable attempt at the Lion, Witch and the Wardrobe was made in the late 1970's by the Children's Television Workshop, which I remember watching in my Grandmother's bedroom as a small boy..

However, the recent version of Prince Caspian lets itself down in other ways that could have been avoided: in particular the liberties taken with the original story. I will describe them in another post.

2 comments:

Matt Doyle said...

You say you liked the 1970s version you remember watching as a small boy in your Grandmother's bedroom. That is very touching. But imagine how excited you would have been if presented with this film version, when that small boy?! This is a children's film and should probably not be subject to your adult criticism about the reality of talking animals and children sword-fighting.

Oliver McCarthy said...

Actually I thought the film-version did an excellent job in covering up some of Lewis's own grave lapses of judgement - such as that the plot makes absolutely no sense whatsoever. After all, why on earth do the Pevensies go back to Narnia when Caspian blows the stupid horn? Did no one think to blow the horn before? And why doesn't Aslan himself just go and help straightaway - given that that's what he ends up doing after dozens of people have died pointlessly? I know in the book he's "not a tame lion", but one would like to think he's not a psychopath either.